"Things do not have to be this way" between the U.S. and Iran
Writing in the New York Times, a former state department member who worked on Iran during the Bush administration, Reza Marashi, explains the U.S.’s real Iran problem: too much emphasis on intelligence and far too little on diplomacy
While serving in the State Department’s Office of Iranian Affairs, I learned the 10 percent rule: intelligence is meant to make up approximately 10 percent of the overall information used to analyze strategic issues. The remaining 90 percent consists of embassy reporting and unclassified, open-source information.
As a whole, this symbiotic process is meant to provide a balanced, broader context to policymakers. Intelligence is supposed to be the missing piece of the puzzle — not the only piece. Overreliance on intelligence to support key policy decisions results in skewed or incomplete analysis that lacks the fuller context needed for sound decision-making. As this information vacuum grows over time, so too does the likelihood of misperceptions, miscalculations and dangerous mistakes.
Intelligence is not a substitute for the critical work of diplomats on the ground — and perhaps no foreign policy issue demonstrates this more forcefully than Iran. Simply put, a vital national security process has been broken for over three decades, and American politicians are exacerbating rather than repairing it.
Read more.
En Español
The Latest
From IPS News
- Who Should be the Next UN Leader?PART 4
- ‘Living in Fear’: Landowners in Uganda’s Oil Field on Brink of Eviction
- Better Incentives Needed to Expand Solar Energy in Cuba
- Africa Pushing Limits To Boost Renewable Energy Supply Chain, Security
- Who Should be the Next UN Leader?PART 3
- Trade Deception Returns in Pan-Africanist Guise
- Solar Power and Biogas Empower Women Farmers in Brazil
- Migration in the Americas: A Dream That Can Turn Deadly
- Rural Entrepreneurs Thriving Against All Odds in Zimbabwe
- Conflict’s Long Shadow Has a Name: It’s Hunger
- Online fundraising for IPS Inter Press Service at Razoo