• Thursday, October 2, 2014
  • A program of IPS Inter Press Service supported by the Dutch MDG3 Fund

    Fake watches, artificial limbs and real needs

    Ads about diamond-and-sapphire studded watches don’t turn me on. But this one gripped me. fake-horiz-croppsp

    A screw-on  hand and the slogan:  “Fake watches are for fake people. Be authentic. Buy real.”

    The ad is part of a campaign against counterfeiting launched by the Geneva-based Fondation de la Haute Horlogerie last month.

    I might have ignored it but the day I saw it in a magazine, I had been interviewing amputees and photographing artificial limbs, not unlike the hand in the ad, for a story.

    Ndozi Xhaudi is a 79-year-old grandmother from Botswana who got a prosthetic leg through an aid group in June.  For the first time in years, Xhaudi left the wheelchair and walked.

    Tarina Coetzee, the physiotherapist who helped Xhaudi, recalls that it was her biggest dream to walk again. Now she could make tea and food for herself and be less of a burden on her family.

    I spent time in Pretoria with Mohammad Saib, 13, who was born without legs. He goes to school, runs on the treadmill, and plays paintball thanks to his prostheses – you could call them fake limbs.

    Ndozi Xhaudi. Courtesy ICExpress

    Ndozi Xhaudi. Courtesy ICExpress Progressive Prosthetics

    I stared at the ad.  How would Xhaudi and Saib feel about it?

    I am sure the Fondation and its ad agency did not mean any disrespect. They probably never thought about a link between fake hands and real people with real needs.

    This is part of the problem: the invisibility of people with disabilities.

    Even the Millennium Development Goals forgot them, says the International Disability and Development Consortium. Disability is not included in MDG indicators and targets, although it affects all eight MDGs (see their slideshow).

    Landmines and diamonds

    This is not as surprising as it sounds. Disabled people consistently face discrimination and disadvantage. Eight out of ten live below the poverty line. One in five of the world’s poorest people are disabled, says the Consortium.

    The World Bank estimates there are 300 million women with disabilities, and most live in poor countries. Moreover, women are the main carers of the disabled.

    Women suffer gender-specific disabilities from obstructed labour, domestic violence and female genital mutilation. Blindness, multiple sclerosis and osteoporosis affect more women then men.

    Besides disease, landmines and cluster bombs maim people. So do blood diamonds. In Sierra Leone’s diamond-fueled civil war, rebels hacked people’s arm at the elbow or the shoulder. They offered their victims a choice between  “short sleeve or long sleeve”.

    Last November, a fake (truly fake) satirical ad about blood diamonds annoyed South African diamond De Beers so much it tried to force the web provider to take down the offending website, which featured a hilarious spoof of the New York Times published on line and in print by a group of artists.

    In the fake ad, a white female hand with a glittering diamond ring reaches out to a black prosthetic hand. The punch line: Your diamond purchase will enable De Beers “to donate a prosthetic for an African whose hand was lost in diamond conflicts.”  See it here.

    I have a friend who covered the civil war in Sierra Leone. Up to this day she can’t look at shops that have mannequins without arms. “My friends think I’m weird,” she says.

    I don’t. I think she is sensitive to other realities far away from expensive, status-symbol watches and jewelry stores.

    (Read about people with disabilities in Argentina, India and Tanzania.)

    • mercedes

      Greetings. I could not understand exactly what you meant in your comment. Kindly clarify so it can be posted. Thanks.

    • http://www.selling-watches.com huho

      good aritcle!

    • http://www.swisswuff.ch/tech/?p=205 Discriminating ad – the Fondation de la Haute Horlogerie spits down on amputees as what they call ‘fake people’ alluding at a prosthetic hand : technical right below elbow amputee issues

      [...] http://www.ips.org/blog/mdg3/2009/07/fake-watches-artificial-limbs-and-real-needs/ The full text of their ad for documentation: A global response to counterfeiting worldwide « FAKE WATCHES ARE FOR FAKE PEOPLE ! »The Fondation de la Haute Horlogerie and the Federation of the Swiss Watch Industry are joining forces to launch an international anti-counterfeiting campaign. Their objective is to inform the public on the damage caused by this global scourge. In spite of the many efforts made, the problem of counterfeiting and piracy continues to wreak havoc on virtually every economy worldwide, and is expanding rapidly through multiple distribution channels, especially online. [...]

    • Timothy

      I’m sorry, but this is insane. It’s a hand off of a mannequin, and you think this advert is about amputees? Don’t be paranoid. A mannequin is in fact a fake person, a stand-in for a model, a prop for selling clothing and jewelery. To suggest that this picture degrades and purposefully offends people who are missing limbs is the height of political correctness and worthy of ridicule. To demand that everyone keep in mind every form of affliction and incapacity when creating advertisements in order to avoid the possibility of offending one group or another is not only impractical, it’s deeply stupid. Perhaps we need to make sure that everyone pictured in an advert must wear sunglasses – after all, many people with albinism have to wear sunglasses, and being forced to see media portrayals of people who don’t wear sunglasses might be an offense to them. People who have cancer and take chemotherapy treatments frequently lose all their hair, so should we then ban all media portrayals of people with hair, to shelter their feelings? Where does the stupidity end? In the meantime, the true and worthy point of the original advertisement is lost amid the misdirected outrage and idiotic blather.

    home | top