A Stalemated U.N. in Do-or-Die Session on Action Plan

Posted on 04 June 2012 by admin

By Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Jun 4, 2012 (IPS) – After weeklong negotiations, a meeting of the Preparatory Committee (PrepCom) to finalise a plan of action titled “The Future We Want” for next week’s Rio+20 summit has failed to reach agreement – and deferred a decision to a final three-day session in Brazil.

Rio+20 Secretary-General Sha Zukang expressed confidence the outcome document will be finalised before the summit. Credit: UN Photo/Rick Bajornas

And if that session too ends in a stalemate, as all other previous sessions have, world leaders may have to step in to get directly involved in negotiating the final text.

But, according to one U.N. source, that’s a rare occurrence at mega U.N. conferences where heads of state and government turn up just to endorse the plan – completely oblivious to any of the details negotiated by their diplomatic underlings.

The involvement of world leaders, however, is exactly what Secretary- General Ban Ki-moon has been trying to avoid.

“We must be determined to confront the hard issues now – 100 percent of the issues – instead of kicking the can to Rio,” he warned last month.

Quite simply, he said, “we need a negotiated outcome document before Rio to ensure the high-level participation that we worked so hard to generate.”

He bluntly told member states, “Show the flexibility that it will take to reach agreement on all substantive issues and finalise the outcome document ahead of the conference in Rio.”

But that advice apparently fell on unresponsive ears.

The final three-day session of the PrepCom, comprising all 193 member states, is scheduled to take place Jun. 13-15.

The Rio+20 summit of world leaders, formally called the U.N. Conference on Sustainable Development, will be held Jun. 20-22.

The summit will be preceded by three days of meetings by civil society groups, Jun. 16-18.

Despite the deadlock, the United Nations Monday expressed confidence the outcome document will be finalised before the summit.

“‘I sense a real dialogue – a real willingness to find common ground,” said Rio+20 Secretary-General Sha Zukang. “This spirit is encouraging, and we must carry it to Rio.”

Ambassador Kim Sook of the Republic of Korea, co-chair of the PrepCom, also put a positive spin on the deadlocked negotiations.

“We have accomplished much,” he said, in a statement released Monday.

Before the last round of negotiations, he pointed out, only six percent of the text had been agreed upon. Now, that number has jumped to more than 20 percent, with many additional paragraphs close to agreement.

“So what?” asked a sceptical Patricia J. Lerner, senior political adviser with Greenpeace International.

Lerner told IPS the United Nations seems to be more concerned about the number of paragraphs agreed upon than about concepts.

Outlining U.N. expectations, Sha said the latest negotiations have given the process a sense of confidence that “we can deliver to the world an outcome document that would be worthy of our heads of state and government signing.”

He also called “for strong, action-oriented outcomes that would advance progress on key issues such as food security and sustainable agriculture, energy, oceans, gender equality and women’s empowerment, and education”.

And there must be progress on the means of implementing action, including initiatives to strengthen financing, technology transfer and capacity building, in support of sustainable development, he added.

But according to diplomatic sources, some of these issues still remain divisive, mostly on North-South lines.

Addressing the closing sessions Saturday, Sha said the United Nations should be in a position to launch a process at Rio to define sustainable development goals as a central feature of a post-2015 development framework.

He singled out “a few crucial issues” that remain unresolved, including how to ensure that the goals integrate the economic, social and environmental dimensions of sustainable development; the process to develop Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs); and, perhaps most importantly, the priority areas for possible goals.

Other areas where Rio +20 can make a difference, he said, would be agreement to explore and share experiences and knowledge of green economy policy options as tools to advance sustainable development and poverty eradication, and to make decisions on key elements of the international institutions needed to support sustainable development, according to a statement released here.


Download PDF File

Download TERRAVIVA PDF File   Download TERRAVIVA PDF File


Expo Milano

Photos from our Flickr stream

See all photos


Terraviva talks to Giuseppe Sala, CEO of EXPO Milano 2015 Expo Milano 2015 is in Rio to kick off its global dialogue on food and energy. During a side on June 21, CEO Giuseppe Sala gives an overview of the Expo 2015 that will run from May to October in Milan, Italy.more >>.

Upcoming Events


RSS News from our partners

  • Are you ready to Connect4Climate?
    World Bank's social media campaign engaged African youth caring about climate change.
  • Natural capital accounting
    Thomson Reuters Foundation and the World Bank have jointly produced a video explaining the concept of “natural capital accounting” in the run-up to the Rio+20 summit on sustainable development. The seven-minute video news release (VNR) was created as part of a World Bank campaign for countries to carry through on promises to include the full [...]
  • IUCN World Conservation Congress
    IUCN, the International Union for Conservation of Nature, is a long standing member of COM+. It helps the world find pragmatic solutions to our most pressing environment and development challenges by supporting scientific research; managing field projects all over the world; and bringing governments, NGOs, the UN, international conventions and companies together to develop policy, [...]
  • IFC, Union for Ethical BioTrade Encourage Businesses to Protect Biodiversity in Latin America
    Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, June 17, 2012—IFC, a member of the World Bank Group, and the Union for Ethical BioTrade today announced an agreement at the Rio+20 Conference to increase private sector awareness of biodiversity and strengthen market frameworks for protecting it in Latin America. In addition to aiding environmental conservation, the partnership will help [...]
  • Rio de Janeiro e Banco Mundial lançam inĂ©dito Programa de Desenvolvimento de Baixo Carbono da Cidade
    RIO DE JANEIRO, 18 de junho de 2012 – A Cidade do Rio de Janeiro e o Banco Mundial lançaram hoje, durante a CĂşpula dos Prefeitos – evento paralelo Ă  ConferĂŞncia das Nações Unidas sobre Desenvolvimento Sustentável-Rio+20 –, um programa pioneiro na esfera municipal para colocar em prática ações para o desenvolvimento de baixo carbono [...]

Sponsors and Partners of TerraViva Rio + 20


TerraViva is an independent publication of IPS Inter Press Service news agency. The opinions expressed in TerraViva do not necessarily reflect the editorial views of IPS or the official position of any of its sponsors or partners.