Daniel Larison at the American Conservative has an interesting take on U.S. President Barack Obama’s endorsement of India’s bid to join the permanent five members of the UN Security Council (those who wield veto power), and what it says about the United State’s policy of steadfast objection to the Iranian nuclear program.
Larison (with my emphasis):
The more interesting question is whether the U.S. is able to acknowledge that major and rising powers do not share its preoccupations and to adjust expectations of their cooperation with U.S. policy accordingly. Washington isn’t likely to abandon its fixation on Iran’s nuclear program, but it should give the administration some pause that it has just publicly endorsed permanent Security Council status for what is, in fact, one of the chief “rogue” nuclear states in the world. This is not a criticism of the administration’s engagement of India. On the contrary, the administration’s correct dealing with India stands as a rebuke to the administration’s Iran policy. Further, the favorable treatment shown to nuclear-armed India confirms that states that never join and flatly ignore the requirements of the NPT and go on to build and test nuclear weapons are not censured or isolated in the least. Instead, they are rewarded with good relations and high status. More to the point, if the administration had what it wanted and India were on the Security Council as a permanent member with veto powers, how much weaker would U.N. sanctions against Iran have had to be to satisfy India? Put another way, if India is ready to be considered such an acceptable and responsible power, what does Indian indifference to Iran’s nuclear program tell us about the rationality of our government’s obsessive hostility towards the same?
(Via Andrew Sullivan.)
- COP28: Sowing Seeds of Change in Fertile Hearts and Minds
- Greening Education: Education Paying Highest Cost for Ongoing Climate Crisis
- Renewable Commitments at COP28 Pose Stiffer Energy Challenges for Latin America
- For Africans, the Climate Debate Around the Role of Livestock Misses the Mark
- Why Climate Justice and Global Financial Reform Are Inseparable
- Harmful Industry Blowing Smoke on Human Rights
- COP28 Hits: Key Wins as Africa-Focused Pledges, Deals Announced
- Faith Pavilion Adds Spiritual Dimension to Climate Crisis Resolution
- Combating Corruption to Address the Triple Planetary Crises
- COP28: Climate Migrants’ Rights, Risk-based Labor Polices Under the Spotlight